Interpret a fraction as the equal share of a whole-number quantity.
The original lesson PDFs remain version 1.0.0. This supplement adds diagnostic probes, teaching responses, and question-specific rubrics. Use the supplement below for the updated guidance.
Ask for an explanation or drawing before choosing a response. A wrong answer alone does not identify its cause.
Question-by-question misconception guide and open-response criteria
Use these as follow-up prompts, then examine the learner’s model or explanation. Open responses may differ from the sample while satisfying the criteria.
c1: 3 identical loaves are shared equally by 4 people. How many loaves does each person get?
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
c2: 2 identical loaves are shared equally by 3 people. How many loaves does each person get?
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
c3: 5 identical loaves are shared equally by 6 people. How many loaves does each person get?
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
c4: 4 identical loaves are shared equally by 3 people. How many loaves does each person get?
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
Watch for: Restarts the fraction count or changes the denominator after passing one.
Try: Place two equal-length unit strips end to end, both split into fourths. Label 0/4, 1/4, …, 8/4 continuously. Circle 4/4 at one and take one more unchanged quarter-step to 5/4.
c5: 7 identical loaves are shared equally by 4 people. How many loaves does each person get?
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
Watch for: Restarts the fraction count or changes the denominator after passing one.
Try: Place two equal-length unit strips end to end, both split into fourths. Label 0/4, 1/4, …, 8/4 continuously. Circle 4/4 at one and take one more unchanged quarter-step to 5/4.
c6: 1 identical loaves are shared equally by 5 people. How many loaves does each person get?
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
c7: 5 identical loaves are shared equally by 8 people. How many loaves does each person get?
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
c8: 6 identical loaves are shared equally by 5 people. How many loaves does each person get?
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
Watch for: Restarts the fraction count or changes the denominator after passing one.
Try: Place two equal-length unit strips end to end, both split into fourths. Label 0/4, 1/4, …, 8/4 continuously. Circle 4/4 at one and take one more unchanged quarter-step to 5/4.
s1: Share 1 same-sized wholes equally among 2 people. Find one share.
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
s2: Share 1 same-sized wholes equally among 3 people. Find one share.
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
s3: Share 2 same-sized wholes equally among 4 people. Find one share.
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
s4: Share 3 same-sized wholes equally among 3 people. Find one share.
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
h1: Draw the equal sharing of three wholes among four people.
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
Look for in the response:
- Show three same-sized wholes and four recipients.
- Partition and distribute so every recipient receives an equal amount.
- Identify each share as three fourth-pieces, or 3/4 of one whole.
h2: Explain why a/b can represent a ÷ b.
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
Look for in the response:
- Interpret a as the number of wholes and b as a positive number of equal shares.
- Explain that each whole contributes a 1/b piece to every share.
- Conclude that each share receives a such pieces, giving a/b = a ÷ b.
h3: Give a sharing story with a share greater than one whole.
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
Watch for: Restarts the fraction count or changes the denominator after passing one.
Try: Place two equal-length unit strips end to end, both split into fourths. Label 0/4, 1/4, …, 8/4 continuously. Circle 4/4 at one and take one more unchanged quarter-step to 5/4.
Look for in the response:
- Create a story with more wholes than recipients.
- Share equally and identify the measurement unit.
- Calculate a share greater than one, such as 5/4 loaf for five loaves and four people.
h4: Check a 2/3 share for three people.
Watch for: Confuses the number of equal groups with the size of each group.
Try: Draw three separate bags, each holding 2/5 cup. Label “3 groups” and “2/5 cup per group.” Count six fifth-cup pieces in total and connect the drawing to 2/5 + 2/5 + 2/5.
Look for in the response:
- Interpret 2/3 as the amount per person.
- Multiply by the three people.
- Show 3 × 2/3 = 2, recovering the original two wholes.
e1: Calculate 3 ÷ 4. Show a model or your reasoning.
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
e2: What does the denominator count in an equal-sharing story?
Watch for: Reverses wholes and recipients in an equal-sharing quotient.
Try: Draw three loaves and four recipient spaces. Cut every loaf into fourths and give one fourth from each loaf to every person. Each receives 3/4 loaf; four shares recover the original three loaves.
Look for in the response:
- Identify the denominator as the number of equal shares or people.
- Explain that this determines each whole’s partition in the sharing model.
- Connect to 3 ÷ 4 by naming four recipients and 3/4 per person.